Whole Stuffed Lobster

If you’re looking for an elegant yet easy dinner, this baked stuffed lobster recipe is for you! Made with simple pantry ingredients, it’s sure to impress!

seafood stuffed lobster on serving platter with lemon slices


 

One of the most awe inspiring dishes ever to grave menus and come out of a kitchen is a whole baked lobster. They aren’t magical or mystical, only stuffed with pricy ingredients and therefore reserved only for special occasions.

Baked Whole Stuffed Lobster

When you crave stuffed lobster you have the choice or doing just a tail or the whole darn lobster. Both are impressive and both make a statement.

whole baked stuffed lobster with butter

Whole lobsters are a little more challenging because you will need to start with a live lobster while tails you can get frozen and just defrost. For some, the whole live lobster thing is off putting.

Seafood Stuffing

There are many recipes for lobster stuffing but the one thing all the top rated versions have in common: LOADS OF SEAFOOD.

seafood stuffing in a skillet

What seafood mixture you ultimately toss into the mix is up to you. Popular options include:

  • Bay or sea scallops
  • Shrimp
  • Crab
  • Additional lobster meat
  • Haddock
  • Canned tuna

From there, you’ll need a binder. I used panko bread crumbs for these whole stuffed lobsters because I like their larger size for texture. They are like little flavor bombs that fill with liquid and keep your stuff from drying out. Other options are saltine cracker crumbs, regular seasoned bread crumbs or ground croutons.

angle close up of stuffed lobster

After the bread and seafood are combined with onion and garlic, I use a small amount of liquid to make it into a paste before stuffing it on my lobster.

Other seasonings include blackened seasoning, Italian or smoked paprika. My new favorite seasoning aleppo pepper is also a winner if you liked a spicy, smoky mix.

Servings

One of the most popular questions we get it how many people one whole stuffed lobster will serve and the honest answer is that it depends on the size of the lobster and how hungry your diners are.

fork digging into a seafood stuffed lobster

One standard 1 1/2 pound lobster is supposed to feed 2 people, but my husband would laugh at you. I typically pair it was a nice cut of beef like filet mignon or pan fried steak. The ultimate surf and turf.

The tail meat has the most weight, so judge how much you’ll be eating on this and then add more seafood stuffing as needed. This recipe is a loose estimate, you can use more or less stuffing to fit your needs.

Prepping your Whole Stuffed Lobster

This is the nice way of saying you are going to have to kill the lobster and if you don’t have the will to do this, I won’t judge you, but it needs to happen.

There is a lot of discussion on how to humanely kill a lobster and when it comes down to it, there are 3 ways that are considered to be acceptable: boiling/steaming head first, sharp knife between the eyes and cutting off the tail.

lemon butter stuffed lobster

First, let it be known that experts believe that lobsters do not feel pain, although they do sense changes in temperature. Their nervous system is purely skeletal and resembles that of an insect. They also have no brains. You can’t be scared or feel pain without a place to process it.

They also do not have vocal chords, so the myth that they will scream when put in the pot is also false. There might be noise, but it is just spitting of the cold lobster going into a hot pot.

Whatever you do, keep your lobster cold in the fridge until you are ready to do it. This slows down their reflexes and keeps them calm. For this whole stuffed lobster recipe, you really only have one choice: knife behind the eyes.

halved lobster in a baking dish

You’ll be splitting the body down the center lengthwise, but not fully cutting the two pieces apart so it butterflies out for the stuffing.

Knife Behind the Eyes

If you look at the back of a lobster, you’ll see a little cross in the shell. Aim there with a chef’s knife and stab in the middle. This disconnects the nervou system immediately. Some will say it is stabbing them in the brain, but they don’t have a brain so that isn’t possible.

where to stab a lobster behind the eyes

Their legs may move around a little, this is purely reflex. They are now dead. This part is hard, I know. It takes a little practice.

How To Make Stuffed Lobster

The process is really quite easy after you’ve done it once or twice. I suggest making the seafood stuffed first then tackling your lobster.

  1. Cook finely chopped onion and garlic and cook for 2-3 minutes, or until opaque in melted butter. Add seafood of choice.
  2. Add chopped parsley, panko and Kosher salt, browning lightly.
  3. Form a paste using lemon juice and water. Cool slightly while preparing the lobster.
  4. At this point, prep and broiled a halved lobster. Remove when cooked.
  5. Mound on top of broiled lobster and top with remaining panko.
  6. Bake for about 8 minutes, then switch over to broil for 1-2 minutes until crisp and golden. I like it when my stuffing is crisp.
  7. Meanwhile, melt more butter for topping. Pour over cooked lobster with stuffing. You can season with salt, if desired.
  8. Serve immediately with lemon wedges for spritzing and make sure to take lots of pictures to show all your friends on Facebook and Instagram the glory of your lobster!
whole stuffed lobster for pinterest

More lobster recipes:

A lobster on a table

Whole Steamed Lobster

3.95 from 17 votes
How to humanely kill a live lobster, how to steam lobster, lobster cooking times and step-by-step images for eating whole lobster!
See The Recipe!
close up of cooked lobster tail

Best Broiled Lobster Tail Recipe

4.70 from 13 votes
Broiled Lobster Tails are seasoned and basted with lemon butter (and a secret ingredient!) Ready in just 10 minutes!
See The Recipe!
overhead of cold lobster salad on a plate with greens

Best Recipe for Lobster Salad

4.56 from 34 votes
Lobster Salad is perfect for a light lunch or dinner! Serve on top of greens or even in a roll, which is known as a Cold Lobster Roll or New England Roll.
See The Recipe!
lemon butter stuffed lobster for pinterest
whole stuffed lobster with butter and lemons

Whole Stuffed Lobster

4.73 from 11 votes
If you're looking for an elegant yet easy dinner, this Whole Stuffed Lobster recipe is for you! Made with simple pantry ingredients, it's sure to impress!
Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 30 minutes
Servings: 2

Equipment

Ingredients

Lobster:

Seafood Stuffing:

Instructions

Lobster:

  • Preheat oven to broil.
  • In the bottom of a roasting pan, combine white wine with enough water to come up about 1-2 inches in the pan. Set aside.
  • Cut the lobster in half lengthwise by inserting a very sharp chef’s knife right behind the eyes where you see a cross. Aim for the middle and with a swift and fast cut, dig in. Continue to cut the body in half from head to tail, but do not cut the whole way through. Butterfly the lobster.
  • Remove the “inners” which includes the black stuff (intestine) and green stuff (tomollay). If it is really dirty, you might need to rinse it under cold water.
  • Place in roasting pan and broil in the oven for 8-10 minutes. Times will vary based on your oven and the size of the lobster, so stay alert. When the meat turns to white, it is done. Do not overcook the lobster.
  • Remove lobster and reduce heat to 400 degrees.

Seafood Stuffing:

  • In a medium skillet, heat 1 tablespoon butter.
  • Add any raw seafood, onion and garlic and cook for 2-3 minutes, or until opaque.
  • Add any cooked seafood to heat through.
  • Add chopped parsley, 1/2 cup panko and Kosher salt, browning lightly for 1 minute.
  • Add lemon juice and water slowly until panko forms a paste. You might not need all of the liquid.
  • Mound on top of broiled lobster. Press remaining 1 tablespoon of panko on top of seafood stuffing.
  • Cook at 400 for 8-10 minutes. If you want a browned crust, return to broil for 1-2 minutes.
  • Meanwhile, melt remaining 2 tablespoons of butter. Pour over cooked lobster with stuffing.
  • Serve immediately with lemon wedges for spritzing.
  • If you've tried this recipe, come back and let us know how it was in the comments and ratings section!

Notes

Cooked seafood and raw seafood need to be seperated. You can use any type you’d like. I used 2 ounces raw bay scallops, 2 ounces raw pink shrimp and 2 ounces cooked blue crab meat. You can use all of the same seafood or mix it up. 

Nutrition

Calories: 486 kcal, Carbohydrates: 16 g, Protein: 36 g, Fat: 20 g, Saturated Fat: 11 g, Cholesterol: 380 mg, Sodium: 1623 mg, Potassium: 373 mg, Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 3 g, Vitamin A: 693 IU, Vitamin C: 10 mg, Calcium: 247 mg, Iron: 3 mg
Author: Jessica Formicola
Calories: 486
Course: Main Course, Main Dish
Cuisine: American
Keyword: baked stuffed lobster, stuffed lobster recipe, whole stuffed lobster
Did you make this recipe?I’d love to see your recipes – snap a picture and mention @savoryexperiments or tag #savoryexperiments!
Jessica Formicola in her ktichen

About the Author

Jessica Formicola

Jessica the mom, wife and food lover behind Savory Experiments. She is obsessed with butter, salt and bacon and spends all her time in the kitchen and behind a camera. Jessica is a contributor to PopKitchen by Parade, Better Homes & Gardens, The Daily Meal Food + Travel and more!

Read More About Jessica

Join The Discussion

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Questions and Reviews

  1. 5 stars
    I didn’t think lobster could get any more decadent, but this rich decadent recipe takes the cake. So good

  2. 5 stars
    I was intimidated to make this but you made it very easy to follow along, thank you so much for the yummy recipe!! Everyone loved it.

  3. 5 stars
    Stuffed lobster sounds absolutely divine! My mouth is watering at the thought of it, it looks so delicious!

  4. 5 stars
    This looks out of this world delicious and tasty! My daughter and I love lobster! Can’t wait to try this!

  5. What a truly impressive meal! I have never tried cooking a lobster … I know, what is wrong with me!? This recipe sounds terrific and definitely not as complicated as one would think! Yum, can’t wait to try this!