Single Serve Edible Cookie Dough

I’ve never met a cookie dough I didn’t like. Raw eggs, raw flour and all. Don’t judge- you never licked a beater as a kid? It’s the best part of making cookies! But now you don’t have to make a whole batch with my single serving edible cookie dough recipe!

 

In fact, I might enjoy cookie dough more than actual baked cookies and I always judge a dessert on the deliciousness of the batter or dough long before the final version is complete. It is funny to me that some folks refer to it as “edible cookie dough”… isn’t it all raw dough?

Edible Cookie Dough Ingredients

You don’t need much for this easy recipe, in fact most folks have all the simple ingredients in their pantry. For a printable list and amounts, see the printable recipe card below.

• White sugar – Otherwise known as granulated sugar, this is the best type to use.
• Brown sugar – This is what gives it that classic cookie dough flavor. Dark brown sugar or light brown sugar works fine. The images here are using a dark sugar which is higher in molasses and result in a darker color of the dough.
• Softened unsalted butter – some folks have swapped out coconut oil with good results. I prefer the flavor of butter. If you use a salted butter, omit the additional salt.
• Chocolate chips or mix-ins – These are optional but definitely recommended. Check the section below for our favorite ideas.
• Milk or water – Whole milk is best, but any type will do. You can also use water if you don’t have any milk.
• Vanilla Extract – Because there aren’t many ingredients in this recipe, I like to make sure to use a good quality vanilla.
• Fine salt – If you ended up using salted butter, omit the salt. You can always add a little at the end if needed.
• All-purpose flour – Just plain, old flour. See instructions below on how to heat treat flour if this is a concern for you. You can use self rising flour, but it contains a leavening agent and since you aren’t baking, you really don’t need that. If you do use it, omit the additional salt.

Variations

There are several ways that you can make this edible cookie dough recipe your own. And if you’re missing an ingredient, there are plenty of options!

• Flour– If you don’t have heat treated flour or have a flour or gluten sensitivity, feel free to use almond meal or almond flour, gluten free flour or some folks have even used pancake mix and buckwheat flour.
• Chocolate Cookie Dough– Readers have also substituted 1 tablespoon of flour with cocoa powder to make a chocolate cookie dough.
• Butter– Butter is best since it is the base. Margarine is acceptable and vegan butter can also be used. All of these will impact the flavor. Ghee is also an option. I like to use unsalted butter so I can control the salt levels. If you use salted butter, you might want to omit additional salt.
• Vanilla– Use any type of extract you’d like, but I do suggest using some extract for flavor. Omitting this ingredient will result in a near flavorless cookie dough. You can use homemade vanilla which will really blow your mind! Almond flavoring is my second favorite with lemon or rum extract trailing behind.
• Brown Sugar– You can use all white sugar, but brown sugar has molasses in it which is why it is softer and has more flavor. You can add a dab of molasses or even dark agave nectar. If you use all white sugar, it is fine, but it will be more like sugar cookie dough.

How to Make Cookie Dough Edible

This raw cookie dough is so easy to make, you might make a batch every week!

1. Soften Butter. This step is the most commonly messed up step and I can no stress enough that your butter must be soft, but not melted. Here are a few ways to soften butter fast. This is also the number one reason you won’t achieve the desired cookie dough texture. After you melt it, it is hard to get back even if you chill the dough.
2. Cream together brown sugar, butter and white sugar. I do this by hand, there really isn’t enough actual batter to require a stand mixer or electric mixer and if the butter is soft enough, it should be easy.
3. Stir in wet ingredients. These include milk/water and the vanilla extract. I like to use milk, but don’t always have it, so water will do. You can also use almond milk or oat milk. Vanilla flavored milk gives you an added bonus!
4. Add the flour. If your butter was soft and not melted, this should be plenty of flour. If your butter was runny, you might need to add a little more, but still, this depends on a lot of things. The main one being that everything was measured correctly. With such small volumes, even a little extra splash of milk can throw off how much flour you require.
5. Add chocolate chips. Chips are totally optional. I would be lying if I said I hadn’t made just the cookie dough without chips before. Some prefer to use mini chocolate chips for a better dough to chip ratio.

Favorite Cookie Dough Mix-Ins

Sure, you can use chocolate chips for a traditional cookie dough taste, but there are plenty of other fun options to try.

How to Heat Treat Flour

Uncooked flour has a small chance of containing some yucky things, so to prevent this, pasteurize it at home. Microwaving is the quickest way. Place raw flour into the microwave (flour alone, not the dough) and heat on high for 20- 45 seconds. Please be mindful that all microwaves are different. Watch the flour closely so it doesn’t burn.

The oven is another good option to heat-treat, simply place it in a thin layer on a baking sheet at 350°F for 5ish minutes. Just make sure it doesn’t burn. This should be plenty to kill off any harmful bacteria.

Easy Edible Cookie Dough Recipe FAQs

More Cookie Dough Recipes

Love this recipe like I do? Here are a few more cookie dough recipes you might enjoy.