By the time you finish reading this, in which case you might have already scrolled through, you are going to think I am a loon. An everything bagel obsessed loon. And you will be right.
What's In This Article
Everything Bagel Seasoning
A a littlely buttered toasted bagel might be my ideal breakfast. Second to Eggs Benedict, but let’s be real, that only happens a few times per year. So we have to be realistic.
Until I met the everything bagel, shortly followed by everything bagel seasoning.
What type of bagel?
An Everything Bagel is my jam! Why did I wait so long to try you, my love?
I used to opt for a sesame seed bagel, but one day the sesame seed bagels got a little too close to the everythings bagels and the seasoning encroached on a small subsection.
The bite was pure bliss. I actually went back to the counter and ordered an everything bagel and tossed the sesame seed. Sorry sesame, but you are now second best.
What is in it?
Ever since, I have been on the hunt for the perfect everything bagel and a few have come close. The basic ingredients are simple:
- sesame seeds
- dried minced garlic (onion flakes)
- dried minced onion (garlic flakes)
- poppy seeds
- coarse salt (Kosher salt)
Small mom-and-pop shops and big chains alike add special ingredients or more or less of one or the other.
And of course, you have to rate the actual bagel. You can put the best seasoning mix in the world on a crappy bagel and it will go nowhere.
Oddly enough, the hospital I used to work at had the BEST everything bagels I ever sank my teeth into. You had to get there early, as everyone knew and they only made about a dozen per day.
The bagel was so darn good, I didn’t even toast it. Yep, bagel-in-the-raw with some butter and it was magical. Their trick is to add extra salt.
It’s All About the Salt
And we all know I am a sucker for good salt.
The bagel shop near me, THB, also makes a good whole wheat everything bagel, but sometimes the toppings are skimpy and I didn’t sign on for a plain bagel.
No way. Theirs also seem to be getting smaller and smaller…
On the day I decide to splurge and carbo-load, I want the biggest darn everything bagel I can get! They have a good bagel dough to start, so this gives it a kick.
My third favorite is Einstein’s Bagels and this is because they add a fifth ingredient that is quite polarizing, caraway seeds. There aren’t many, maybe every fifth bite, but they are there and so darn tasty!
To customize your own Everything Bagel Seasoning, add equal amounts caraway seeds, crushed fennel, different varieties of salt like pink Himalayan or black sea salt, black sesame seeds and more.
Now that I’ve got you just as obsessed as me, go make a batch of homemade everything bagel seasoning.
It stays fresh stored in an airtight container in the pantry for up to a year which also makes it a great gift!
Seasoning for more than bagels!
Now what to put it on? Cause I bet most of you aren’t sitting around making bagels, even on the weekends. Here are some of my favorites ideas:
- Avocado toast
- Meatball Stromboli
- Sprinkled on top of pizza
- Baked potatoes
- Scrambled eggs
- Dinner rolls or toast
- Seasoning for chicken, fish or pork
- Garlic Bread
Do you have a recipe for bagels?
Nope. I don’t mess around with making my own bagels. There are a couple of things that are just better left to the pros in my world.
The first is pie crust. I loathe pie crust. The second are bagels (and most bread). I try my best and can do basic dinner rolls, but actual loaves of bread or sandwich buns aren’t in my wheelhouse. Bagels fall into that category.
Storage & Shelf Life
How long does everything seasoning blend last? Months! It doesn’t really have anything in it that goes bad and salt is a natural preservative.
Simply place it in an airtight container in your pantry and use it when you need it.
If you prefer to make homemade seasonings like I do, here are a few more to check out!
Everything Bagel Seasoning
- 1 tablespoon sesame seeds
- 1 tablespoon poppy seeds
- 1 tablespoon dried onion flakes
- 1 tablespoon dried garlic flakes
- 1 tablespoon coarse sea salt
- Mix all ingredients together in a bowl and use on whatever you please!
- Everything Bagel Mix will keep fresh in an airtight container at room temperture for up to a year.
- If you’ve tried this recipe, come back and let us know how it was!
Do yourself a favor and make this with half cups or whole cups instead of tablespoons, well maybe not the sesame seeds, but definitely the rest. We have a local store that sells it in a big jar, probably about 2 cups volume-wise, which is great because there isn’t a TJs in my state and the little bottles don’t go very far. I sprinkle a bit on my low carb mug buns.
LOL, I couldn’t agree more, Davette! We eat this on everything- everything seasoning ON everything!
I had no idea of creating our own bagel seasoning. Thanks for sharing the recipe. Can’t wait to try!
I am probably one of the only ones who hasn’t tried the everything bagel mix. Now you have peaked my curiosity. I’ll have to find a bagel shop close by and try it.
You don’t know what you are missing!
I am living in Australia and my daughter from the States sent me this seasoning . It’s fantastic. What a game changer to use on foods.
Glad you love it!!!
I love this recipe! Will try it as soon as possible! Waiting for more soon
I have never thought of creating my own everything bagel seasoning. I just always buy it from TJ’s. I can’t wait to try your recipe.
This will be great on so many things. What a perfect recipe! I love the idea of putting this on crackers or even some homemade chips. So versatile!
This is so nice and I better make this to be use in every recipe that I am going to make, thank you!
This would be great to have on hand. Thanks for sharing this recipe.
Yum! MY kids love everything bagel seasoning and are always asking for me to make a batch. Now I can!
Oh my goodness! I love Everything Bagels surprisingly because I don’t usually like to combine flavors like this. Thank you for this seasoning mix recipe, I am going to make it!
Now this looks like a great seasoning. I love the sound of it!
This gets five stars for sure. I just found a bagel recipe the other day that I want to try, and this seasoning mix is going on there!
Ooo this looks good. I need to give this a try. I’ve heard great things about this seasoning.
I LOVE LOVE LOVE TJ’s EVERYTHING But the Bagel seasoning. In fact, I have 2 jars in my pantry right this moment. I may have to try this because I’m going out less and less and besides it’ll save a few bucks.
I use fennel seeds for garlic bread, and caraway seeds on a Ruben. Love this seasoning on asparagus. Thanks.
That sounds amazing- thanks for coming back to let us know!
A recipe after my own heart! I absolutely love love love an “everything bagel” As a matter of fact, it’s the only one I normally eat so to have this simple recipe that I can whip up so quickly and put on pretty much anything is absolute yummmm!
Love the idea to this recipe. Great to have it as topping for my parties. Gifting option also sound great.
YES!! Thank you for this!! I’ve been longing to try Everything Bagel Seasoning but it hasn’t gotten to Sweden yet… and now I can make it myself!
This sounds like something I will definitely be obsessed with! So much flavor!
Such a delicious combination of flavors. I’ve always loved it — on EVERYTHING! 😀 Great recipe to have on hand!