There is more than one way to boil a hot dog and you will be blown away by the delicious and most importantly, easy options there are. It is all about flavor optimization and then, of course, your favorite toppings.
And just like boiling corn, you might be surprised at how good it tastes!
What's In This Article
Cooking Hot Dogs
This might be an inflammatory statement, but there is a case to be made for Boiling Hot Dogs. I know what you are thinking and I will start off by saying, yes, they are in fact delicious. I guess that is a matter of personal preference, but you at least have to give them a try.
And I know this because all of New York City can’t be wrong. They are boiling people!
They are a great alternative when you don’t have the time to grill or if you simply don’t have a grill to work with. And while it doesn’t make them any healthier, think of the liquid as a vehicle to get even more flavor into your dogs.
How to Boil Hot Dog
Hot dogs are almost always fully cooked when you purchase them at the store. What you need to do at home is warm them up for optimal tastiness.
This process is more about heating them through and adding a little flavor along the way. Be careful not to cook them too long or they will get mushy.
When using this method, never split your dog or poke holes in it. You want to keep it sealed to the meat inside doesn’t dry out or lose its texture. You can use frozen hot dogs, just add a few minutes to the cooking time.
You have two options when it comes to your vessel. You can fill a large, wide and deep saute pan with an inch or two of liquid. This method can make it hard to flavor your liquid however, so I go a different route.
I find the best thing to do is use a 4-quart saucepan about halfway. I am partial to a large pot or saucepan because it is easier to fit your seasonings while not crowding your dogs in the liquid.
Bring to a boil over medium high heat and cook until steaming hot. Remove the hot dogs(about 8-10 minutes) and dab dry with a paper towel. You don’t want the water to sog up the bun.
Then dress them how you see fit.
Flavored Boiling Water
You have to flavor that liquid! Don’t get me wrong, water will work, but if you can layer on the flavor, why wouldn’t you?!
Here’s the reasoning. Hot dogs aren’t watertight. The casing they are in is actually permeable meaning flavor can go in.
Think of it as a stock. You wouldn’t just use plain water for soup now, would you? I didn’t think so. Translation, flavor that water.
Heat up some water with a bit of bouillon. Chicken or beef are both great, but vegetable bouillon will work in a pinch too. If you want a more adult flavor, you can substitute the water for beer or make Bacon and Beer Sauerkraut.
You will boil off the alcohol so it will still be kid-friendly. Either option is delicious.
I like to add a few aromatics and herbs to keep things lively – think an onion, or some garlic, fresh parsley, and whole spices like cumin seeds. If you want a more beer hall flavor profile, add one or two whole star anise instead of the cumin.
Past that, it is all about the toppings. Whether you are a purist who thinks that a dog should only come with mustard or someone who is a fan of maximizing their toppings with chili, cheese, and frizzled onions, you won’t ever stop to think, “Wow, I wish I had grilled these.”
Hot Dog Toppings:
- Spicy ketchup
- Caramelized Onions
- Yum Yum Sauce
- Honey Habanero Pickles
- French Fried Onions
- Crumbled Bacon
- Rochester Sauce
- Tennessee Hot Sauce
- Hot Dog Chili
Hot Dogs in Crock Pot
Making hot dogs in the crockpot is also a good option. It is super easy, but takes a little more time. The benefits are that it is good for parties and to keep your dogs hot.
Set your slow cooker to the low settings and combine the same ingredient in the bowl, stirring to blend. Add hot dogs and cook on low for 1 hour, or until dogs are warm.
Change to the “keep warm” setting and they will be good for hours! Set up your hot dog bar toppings right next to the slow cooker and you are good to go!
More easy meals:
How to Boil Hot Dogs
- 2 quarts water or 4 12oz cans of beer
- 2-4 bouillon cubes , beef or chicken flavor
- 1 head of garlic , cut in half crosswise, skin on
- 1 small yellow onion cut in half , skin on
- small bunch parsley
- 1 tablespoon whole cumin seeds OR 1 or 2 whole star anise
- 8 package your favorite hot dogs
- 8 hot dog buns
- favorite toppings
- Heat the liquid and dissolve the bouillon cubes into it. Add the garlic through the cumin seeds and heat on medium-high until you reach a rolling boil. Drop the heat down to a simmer and allow the flavors to meld. This will also boil off the alcohol in the beer if you are using that as your liquid.
- Turn the heat off and add your hot dogs gently into the pot. Allow them to warm through. This should take 2-4 minutes depending on how cold they are when they go in.
- Pull them out of the water and allow them to drain briefly on a paper towel-lined plate. Serve on toasted buns with your favorite toppings.
- If you’ve tried this recipe, come back and let us know how it was!
First time flavoring the water. Used Bright Leaf hot dogs and Red Hots. Definitely flavoring this way from now on!
Woohoo! So glad you loved it- so many people turn their noses up before even trying it. LOL.
My son will definitely try this recipe out. I’m sure the hot dogs will come out very tasty and flavorful.
I will definitely make this for my sons!
This is so helpful! Great recipe!
What’s up, after readcing this awesome post i am as well delighteed
to share my experience here with friends.
Hot dogs are not usually the kids favourite (weird I know!) but we’ve never tried to boil them before. May have to give it a go!
I am from NY and we love our hot dogs but boy I never thought of flavoring the water. Such a game changer!
Hahaha! I was skeptical at first, but it certainly makes for a good hot dog!
While I don’t eat meat, this tip will come in handy when my family have a craving for hot dogs. Thank you for sharing!
I usually grill or boil my hot dogs, but I haven’t boiled them in forever. I think it’s time to throw some hot dogs on for the kids!
You’ll be surprised how good they are!
I grew up on boiled hot dogs but never with flavored water! I’m glad I know I have options now! Great post!
I had never heard of flavoring the hot dog water before this. Such a great flavor booster!