Nutter Butter Santa Cookies

  • Jump to Recipe
  • It’s time for Christmas cookies to start flooding the internet. None will be cuter than these Nutter Butter Santa Cookies!

    Close up of Santa Cookie

    It is public knowledge that I suck at decorating cakes, cookies and cupcakes so I am on a never ending hunt for ways to create professional looking baked goods that can be prepared by a shakey 2-year-old.

    Make sure you PIN Nutter Butter Santa Cookies!

    Ingredients for Nutter Butter Santa Cookies

    Because when someone comments about my lack of decor ability, I DO blame it on my 2-year-old. I have zero shame.

    I needed something as simple as my famous Horse Cookies. Which could probably be made into reindeer now that I am looking at them…

    No Bake Horse Cookies are perfect for a Kentucky derby party, triple crown races, or horse themed parties! These horse cookies are the best no bake cookies! #horsecookies #nobakecookies #kentuckyderbyparty

    So back to these cookies. They are the perfect no-bake cookie to fill out your cookie tray, serve at a holiday party or just make with the kiddos.

    Unless someone has a peanut allergy, then these are NOT the cookie to make. You, can however substitute them out with a Milano Cookie.

    Nutter butter cookie dipped in white chocolate

    Be mindful that Milanos don’t have as much surface space, so the cinnamon imperial nose and candy eyes might make the Santa Cookies look slightly disproportionate.

    Chocolate dipped nutter butters on parchment paper

    My personal favorite? Serving these Santa Cookies to Santa and his reindeer on Christmas Eve. It is slightly cannibalistic.

    Like that potato chip commercial when Mrs. Potato Head eats the chips with her husband’s mouth.

    Melted red chocolate

    Now let’s talk about chocolate. The art of melting chocolate. It should be easy, right? Melt the chocolate and ta-da! If only…

    Nutter butter cookies dipped in white and red chocolate

    Melting chocolate, like many other things in the kitchen, is chemistry and science. You need the optimal tempeterure to make sure your chocolate melts to a silky smooth consistency.

    Santa hat snowflakes

    Tips for melting chocolate:

    • Skip the microwave and use a double boiler. The microwave just heats it too fast and too hot.
    • If you do need to use the microwave, use it at 50% power or defrost mode.
    • Don’t fully boil the water in your double boiler. Get it hot enough to melt the chocolate, but not to a rolling boil.
    • Put the top pot on with chocolate after the water has come to temperature.
    • Stir constantly while melting. It should only take a minute or so.
    • Use immediately and while shiny.
    • If chocolate gets too hot, it gets clumpy and matte.
    • You can try to revive it by adding 2 teaspoons of vegetable shortening, but sometimes you are better off just starting over.
    Red hots for nose for Santa cookies

    And if you have someone on your naughty list, you can make this vanilla flavored Black Fudge- the perfect Christmas Coal!

    black fudge on burlap

    If you liked these no bake Christmas cookies, check out these other fun Christmas treats:

    Christmas Dunkaroo Dip
    This Christmas Dunkaroo Dip recipe is a quick, sweet and festive holiday dessert dip that the entire family will love. Ready in just a few minutes! #dunkaroodiprecipe #dessertdips #howtomakedunkaroodip
    Christmas Dunkaroo Dip is a sweet and easy dessert dip, make with box cake mix, whipped topping, Greek yogurt, and lots of festive sprinkles. A great last-minute Christmas recipe!
    Peppermint Sugar Cookies
    close up of peppermint sugar cookies
    With basic pantry ingredients and some crushed peppermint, you are on your to making these delicious and festive Peppermint Sugar Cookies!
    Christmas Swirl Bundt Cake
    Christmas Swirl Bundt Cake Recipe- You won't believe how easy it is to create this beautiful and festive vanilla flavored Christmas Swirl Bundt Cake!
    You won’t believe how easy it is to create this beautiful and festive vanilla flavored Christmas Swirl Bundt Cake!
    Holiday Sprinkled OREO Cookies
    chocolate oreo balls
    Holiday Sprinkled Oreo Cookie Balls are an easy no bake dessert perfect for the holiday season and great to make with kids. No cookie tray or party is complete without them!
    Nutter butter santa cookies for Pinterest

    Questions you might have about how to make Santa Cookies:

    Can I use cookie icing instead of melted chocolate? You can! It takes a little longer to set between coats, but it is surely easier to work with than melted chocolate.

    Why does chocolate sweat? Chocolate sweats when the temperature changes too rapidly, the moisture release. Chocolate covered anything is best kept somewhere between refrigerated and room temperature.

    Finished Santa Cookies on parchment paper

    How should I store my chocolate covered treats? If that is the case and I don’t own a special chocolate covered items refrigerator, then where do I put them? Listen- they are fine in the fridge, just know that they might potentially sweat a little. They will still taste perfectly fine.

    Can I use milk chocolate? Sure! Use milk chocolate, dark chocolate or even semi-sweet chocolate. But obviously, you’ll lose the blue tint.

    Can I just use red food coloring in the white chocolate? I’ve always had trouble getting the red to fully integrate smoothly, so I prefer to use red candy melts.

    santa cookies

    Do you suggest a different type of cookie for those who have a nut allergy? The only other cookie I can think of are Milano cookies.

    Get our FREE 8 Day E-Course on How to Be a Better Home Cook. Sign up HERE!

    how to be a better home cook cover


    Be sure to follow me on social media, so you never miss a post!

    Facebook | Twitter | Youtube 
     Pinterest | Instagram 

    Nutter Butter Santa Cookies for Pinterest- the best Christmas Cookies!
    santa cookies
    Print Recipe
    5 from 5 votes

    Nutter Butter Santa Cookies

    If you're looking an an easy, no-bake Christmas cookie, check out my Nutter Butter Santa Cookies! They're super festive, and simple to make.
    Prep Time10 mins
    Drying Time30 mins
    Total Time40 mins
    Course: Dessert
    Cuisine: American
    Keyword: Cookies for Santa, Nutter Butter Cookies, Santa Cookies
    Servings: 20
    Calories: 113kcal


    • Melt white chocolate in a double boiler according to package directions.
    • Dip both ends of each Nutter Butter cookies in white chocolate, leaving some candy showing in the center (for Santa’s face).
    • Place on a parchment lined baking sheet. Allow chocolate to set and harden by air drying or placing in the refrigerator for a few minutes.
    • Next, melt red chocolate. Dip just the top in, leaving a little white strip for the brim of Santa’s hat.
    • Using tweezers, place a white snowflake on the side of the hat for embellishment.
    • Next, attach candy eyes and the cinnamon imperial as the nose with a small dab of frosting or melted white chocolate.
    • Allow to fully set before stacking or packaging.
    • If you’ve tried these cookies, come back and let us know how they were!


    Calories: 113kcal | Carbohydrates: 15g | Protein: 1g | Fat: 6g | Saturated Fat: 3g | Cholesterol: 3mg | Sodium: 49mg | Potassium: 69mg | Fiber: 1g | Sugar: 11g | Vitamin A: 3IU | Vitamin C: 1mg | Calcium: 36mg | Iron: 1mg
    image of jessica formicola

    You Might Also Like...

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published.

    Recipe Rating

    What type of comment do you have?


  • Andrea Metlika wrote:
  • Jack wrote:
  • Irina wrote:
  • Noelle wrote:
  • Kathryn wrote: